Itβs Remembrance Day tomorrow! I wish I could experience all the regular traditions here, but I know the public celebrations are cancelled because of COVID-19. Still, I have made a resolution to learn more about Canadaβs role in WWI and WWII once things calm down with getting settled. Okay, I know the flower emoji Iβm using in the titles is a hibiscus, but I looked it up and it said thatβs acceptable to use it in replacement of a poppy for Remembrance Day. Meanwhile, tech companies need to catch on and create culturally appropriate emojis to make them available for different cultures.
Note: Iβm saying Remembrance Day in my post because thatβs what itβs called in Canada, except when Iβm talking about England. One thing that is making me chuckle right now is learning the meanings and slang terms of different words in Canada. Sometimes, I have to learn another term for something, when I already know two other forms of it in American English and English English! Remembrance Day is one of them because itβs called Armistice Day in the UK and Veterans Day in the US. I wonβt say much about how itβs celebrated in the US, because frankly, it pales in comparison to both the UK and Canada, as far as I have seen.
Iβm rather embarrassed to admit this, but I never bought a poppy in England. I made up for it this time and got a poppy last week! Next time Iβm in England in November, I will get a poppy! I like how the poppies look here. Itβs different from England though. In England, the poppies have a stem on them and they have that definite European poppy look. I think thatβs fair considering you see those poppies all the time in Europe.
It snowed last weekend. I took a walk in a park near where I live and took some pictures. I noticed when I looked at a selfie that I did that it would be nice to put a poppy frame around it, so I did! Iβm glad the snow came back! I think it makes a difference in the photo.
I noticed one thing that is unique to Canada a few days ago. November 8 was Indigenous Veterans Day. I thought that was really cool, considering we donβt have that in the US. I hope someday the US creates a holiday to honour its Indigenous veterans too. Plus, I think they should have days to honour their Black veterans and immigrant veterans.
I ran into this news item a few days ago saying that Whole Foods (which is now owned by Amazon) said their Canadian staff couldnβt wear poppies because it violated the dress code. They thought poppies were a political symbol. I know there was already a backlash from employees this year who were punished for wearing Black Lives Matter masks. I flipped out when I heard about this! Poppies are NOT a political symbol here, or in any country that wears them for November 11! Thank goodness the Canadian government told Whole Foods to reverse the ban on poppies!
Itβs not the first time, I have seen cultural controversy about poppies though. In November 2010, David Cameron offended Xi Jinping when he went on an official trip to China despite being asked not to wear it. Poppies are offensive in China, because of the opium wars. Itβs one of those cultural mistakes that could have been avoided if David Cameron hadnβt been so bloody proud! Sometimes, I think individual expats and Third Culture Kids are more culturally sensitive than global businesses or governments.
I want to take a step back here and talk about what I remember about Armistice Day in England.
When I first moved to England, I noticed things around me that were reminiscent of WWII. In school, we observed the 2-minute silence at 11 AM on November 11. One time, I was at my local library, and all these people who had lived during the war were having a discussion about rationing. I didnβt really pay attention to the things around me that were reminiscent of WWII for a while, and I didnβt understand the poppy symbolism for a while either. Plus, after coming from a country that had engaged in all these useless wars, and then instituted a Patriot Act after 9/11, I was against anything pro-military.
Then, when I was 16, I became really good friends with my neighbour who was a little girl during WWII. She told me all the stories she had about it. Some of them were funny. Some of them were sad. Overall, it was a very personal and human experience.
I had a complete change in mindset about the war too. Both my grandfathers were in the US Navy, so up until I moved to England, I had a US perspective on the war. After I had lived in England for a while, I was rather disgusted when I said to one of my grandfathers that England had won the war, and he said, βBut they didnβt!β
My neighbour shared that she didnβt mind the Americans coming because they were needed to help win the war. She remembered the Americans were always giving the kids gum! She did say, in a culturally sensitive way, that there was a lot of resentment towards Americans for showing up late AGAIN and then taking the credit! I saw it for myself too. I could see that England, as a culture, has a lot of pride in what they did to stand up to Hitler. They deserve to have that pride. They got hit hard with The Blitz and rationing, but they came together and stood up to fascism. What they went through was far different than the US, who sent their boys overseas. Now, I am very pro-England when I hear about WWI and WWII history, and I adopted that when I became a British citizen. One of my favourite shows about England during WWII is Foyleβs War. Itβs a wonderful tribute to that war generation.
One thing I like about Armistice Day in England is that people still stand outside stores and sell poppies. Itβs great for older people to do an activity like that, especially since a lot of them were of that war generation. I had a friend who was born shortly after the war, but she loved selling poppies every November! She was very sociable, so she got a lot of customers, plus she had the endurance to stand in the winter rain! She was one tough cookie! My friend died almost two years ago of cancer. At her funeral, her colleagues from the Royal British Legion laid a poppy wreath on her grave to thank her for her volunteer service. Iβm remembering both my neighbour and my friend at this time.
Since I am still learning about Canadian WWI and WWII history and Remembrance Day traditions, I donβt feel I am in a place to say too much about them. Iβll do a post about it next year though. Iβm looking forward to learning how that fits with the British part too and celebrate those sides of myself.
In closing, Iβm going to put a link to the poem that started the poppy tradition. Itβs been at the forefront of my attention now that I know it was written by a Canadian. Please enjoy the work of physician Lieutenant-Colonel John McCrae!
In Flanders fields the poppies blow Between the crosses, row on row, Β Β Β Β That mark our place; and in the sky Β Β Β Β The larks, still bravely singing, fly Scarce heard amid the guns below. We are the Dead. Short days ago We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow, Β Β Β Β Loved and were loved, and now we lie, Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β In Flanders fields. Take up our quarrel with the foe: To you from failing hands we throw Β Β Β Β The torch; be yours to hold it high. Β Β Β Β If ye break faith with us who die We shall not sleep, though poppies grow Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β In Flanders fields.
Good thoughtful post. I think Remembrance Day captures what is required on this day perfectly. We must remember the Hell of war, the sacrifices of those who fought for our freedoms, those at home who filled the gaps left when soldiers went to war and those who resisted or died in the villages and streets. We must remember, so we can do our utmost so it never happens again. War is not glorious, but freedom s. Stay well. Allan
Thank you. I am still learning about Canadaβs role in the World Wars, but I wanted to write about my time in England too. Thanks for commenting π
Beautiful post ππ
Thank you π
ππ
A couple of days ago #VeteransDay was trending and I thought it was an official date to celebrate war heroes in the USA but maybe I was wrong.
You were right at the beginning, tech companies need to take notes from ya on including much more emojis⦠LoL.
Happy Remembrance Day in Arrears and youβve truly concluded with a remarkable poem Winteroseca.
Finally, I think itβs important for everyone to learn about cultures of certain places before going what is wrong. Like in some parts of Asia, writing peopleβs names in red ink is bad. Regardless of David Cameronβs status, itβll be considered inappropriate if he tried such especially if he knew beforehand.
Veterans Day used to be called Armistice Day in the US, just like in England. My parents remember when they changed it. Now, itβs lost all meaning there.
And right?? Tech needs to keep evolving depending on the culture, especially since symbols mean different things to different cultures.
And thank you! I love that poem too π
You are so right about learning what is acceptable in other countries! I know politicians have protocol departments to help them with that, and you think people would listen to them! I agree that David Cameronβs actions were unacceptable especially since he and the people with him were asked to remove the poppy. I understand an honest mistake, but that wasnβt it! Seeing blatant lack of cultural sensitivity makes me shudder!
So much to learn and thanks for sharing Winteroseca. How long ago was Armistice Day changed in the US and under which administration?
Sorry about my questions, Iβm usually not this inquisitiveβ¦ π
It must have been the 70s or something. My Mum remembers the day it changed and there was an uproar because it was supposed to be there to remember The War to End All Wars. My Mum let me know itβs not okay to forget that the US did that! I took it to heart, especially after my experience in England. Now, publicly remembering the World Wars is dead now, and thatβs not okay!
I like your questions! Keep them coming! π
Thanks. π€
Youβre welcome!
Itβs unbearably sad, the poem, but so very evocative.
I know! I totally agree. Thanks for your comment π
Beautifully post πΊ
Thank you! I have been remembering London a lot at this time. Maybe because Iβm in a Commonwealth country now lol
Beautiful post. Remembrance/Armistice Day traditions are different across the British Commonwealth of which Canada and my birthplace of Guyana are member nations.
Thank you! Yeah, itβs really cool to experience this. Thanks for commenting π